Monday, March 31, 2014

Divided Lines II

Another entry for the list of those who make the smaller portion of the divided line correspond to the intelligible:

H. Dörrie and M. Baltes, Der Platonismus in der Antike. Bd. IV (Stuttgart, 1996), on pp. 332-3 and 342.

That also put me on to: Iamblichus Comm. math. sci. 8 32.8-37.19 Festa (see below) and his discussion of the views of Bro(n)tinus (Pseudo-Brontinus, even) in his Peri nou kai dianoias and Achytas (Pseudo-Archytas, even) in his Peri nou kai aisthēseōs.  But that, I think, would take me into some very odd territory, where I usually fear to tread.  So I might leave that path alone...


(Click on the tools at the bottom of the window to enlarge or turn the page.)

Friday, March 28, 2014

Divided lines

The plan is for us to read some of Plutarch's Quaestiones platonicae at our Thursday seminar next term.  I've been looking at no. 3 (1001C-1002E), in which he wonders whether the smallest of the four segments of the 'divided line' in Republic 6 is supposed to stand for eikasia and its objects (as Proclus has it: In Rem Pub. Plat. or for noēsis and its objects (a view to which Plutarch is at least prepared to give some serious consideration: 1001D-1002B).

I've gone to my bookshelf to see what other people make of it.  Mostly they don't register that there is a decision to be made, though a notable exceptions are: Nicholas Denyer's 'The Sun and Line: the role of the good' in G. R. F. Ferrari (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Plato's Republic (Cambridge, 2007), at 292-4 (Nick turns this into a rather nice point about the nature of this as a diagrammatic representation of something intelligible), and J. Adam's 1902 commentary ad 509d6.  (Adam plumps for eikasia corresponding to the smallest section: see the diagram on p. 65 of vol.2.)

Otherwise, everything I can lay my hands on from where I sit has it that the smallest section stands for eikasia and its objects: 

R. C. Cross and A. D. Woozley, Plato's Republic: a Philosophical Commentary (London, 1964) at 203-5 and 230.
I. A. Richards, Plato's Republic (Cambridge, 1966), at 119.
J. Annas, An Introduction to Plato's Republic (Oxford, 1981), at 247.
C. D. C. Reeve, Philosopher-Kings: the Argument of Plato's Republic (Indianapolis, 1988), diagram on Frontispiece.
S. Scolnicov, Plato's Metaphysics of Education (London, 1988), at 91.
T. Penner, 'The forms in the Republic' in G. Santas ed. The Blackwell Guide to Plato's Republic (Oxford, 2006), 234-62, at 235.


It's not hard to see why: Socrates says that the ratios track 'clarity and unclarity' (σαφηνείᾳ καὶ ἀσαφείᾳ 509d9) and 'truth and untruth' (ἀληθείᾳ τε καὶ μή 510a9) and so I suppose a natural inference is that this means: the larger the line, the greater the clarity.

But has anyone in recent scholarship gone for the un-Proclan view and assigned eikasia and its objects to the largest section?

UPDATE: On 'clarity' here see J. Lesher,  'The meaning of "saphēneia" in Plato's Divided Line', in M. L. McPherran, Plato's Republic: A Critical Guide (Cambridge, 2010), 171-87.

A Google image search for 'plato divided line' throws up some interesting variants.  Quite a few diagrams do not divide the line unequally.  And although the Proclan version is the most common, there are examples of the alternative.  For example:


I found that one at: http://www.angelfire.com/journal2/farmville/eidisi/philosophy/plato.html (from the 'Eidisi Academy of Higher Learning'...)

Here's another from: http://www.mc.maricopa.edu/~barsp59601/text/101/notes/epistemology/plato.html



And a third from: http://plato-dialogues.org/essay_en.htm


Plato as a poster-boy

This is fun.  A firm in the US, Litographs, produces coloured prints (or t-shirts or bags) of the text of classic works arranged as a poster.  There are lots to choose from, including Plato's Republic (the Jowett translation).  Heffers stocks some of them (though they are quite pricey in £ compared with the $ cost listed on the website).  Here's a quick idea of what they look like.  To get the whole text you have to buy the largest size (30 x 45 inches).

Close-up

Full poster

Monday, March 24, 2014

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Death, humanism, Stephen Fry

Here is one of a series of little films made by the British Humanist Association. This one is about death.  It's pretty good, a bit dogmatic (perhaps polemical), but no more dogmatic than the position it's evidently designed to counter.  For the most part, it's a point of view I think is on the right lines, but this presentation of it cuts corners.  For example, it is true there is no strong evidence for post mortem disembodied survival.  But the observed phenomena don't rule it out.  It should also, I think, have recognised that agreeing that death is annihilation does not necessarily bring with it the idea that death is not harmful.  People can die too soon, lives can be cut short, and some people can die too late.  But there is plenty here that someone like Lucretius might have applauded (or asked to be credited for), including the rather nice argument that reading a book is nice, but reading a book that never ends would not be nice.  Finally, while I quite like Stephen Fry, his voice here does have ever so slight a note of smugness...



Monday, March 17, 2014

Taster Days at the Faculty of Classics

A generous donation enables us to invite you to be part of a new initiative addressed to Schools in the maintained sector. 

Click here to download the flyer.



If you're interested in visiting the Faculty with your school, please get in touch with Jennie Thornber to discuss individual needs. We are very happy to arrange a tour of the Faculty's Museum of Classical Archaeology, and to discuss the possibility of a talk with a Cambridge academic and a visit to one of the Colleges.

Please contact Jennie at or (01223) 767044. We look forward to hearing from you.

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

Conference, 21-22 March: Approaching Ancient Philosophy

The ancient philosophy graduates in the Faculty of Classics have organised a conference for March 21st and 22nd.  I think this is the third such event, which is entirely organised and run by the graduate students.  Here is a link to the conference website for more details.  Or click to enlarge the flyer below.


Thursday, March 06, 2014

Williams on Parmenides

I've been dipping into the recently published collection of Bernard William's reviews, lectures and other essays: Essays and Reviews 1959-2002.  (Here's a review of the reviews by Mary Beard in the Guardian.)  There's some strident stuff in there and it's a very mixed bag in all sorts of ways.  But one of the things I like about his writing is that he writes well.  True, this might lend an air of slick superciliousness at times and at other times it's hard to know just what he wants to say because it is either very condensed or just plain suggestive rather than explicit.  ('Add water', you might be advised.)

Here's an example.  He is reviewing Nozick's Philosophical Explanations, which he dubs 'the Great American Novel of philosophy' (that is not an unadulterated compliment), and is wondering  whether any philosophical works have successfully been set out as deductions from a small number of axioms.
At the very beginning of Western philosophy, Parmenides' poem (or half of it) may have tried to do that, but it is hard to tell from its ruins - except that they seem more like the ruins of a temple than of a tower.
That's a marvellously suggestive claim and, typically, nothing more is said to explain just what Williams means by the temple/tower contrast.  I wouldn't let a student get away with writing that in an essay without scrawling a big question mark in the margin.  But it's a thought that lingers and might just turn into another longer and better thought later.  I like philosophical writing that does that.  Plain-speaking and relentless clarity and explicitness is all well and good but it's a chore to read and it leaves you dry-mouthed and gasping for water.




Monday, March 03, 2014

Judging a book

I'm about (at last) to submit my book to CUP.  I've spent the morning trying to chase the last loose ends (just one bit of bibliographica left to tie down) and then completing CUP's 'Marketing questionnaire'.  That asks me to detail any competitor publications on the market and note their strengths and weaknesses.  (Apparently 'I didn't write it' won't count as a good answer to either of these.)  It also asks me to list the major review journals and websites that might be bothered to include the book and their contact details.  I'm pretty sure CUP know how to contact The Classical Review so I left that bit blank.

This is the grim end of publishing, and I'm nowhere near yet the hell of XML indexing...

But all the same I've been cheered along by some of these:


If you're cleverer than I am then you could make them yourself.

The other big task is to try to find a cover.  I didn't have a picture on either of my first two books so I don't have much experience of this.  But I'm pretty sure I don't want just another marble bust of some beardy old philosopher or, perhaps worse, some picture from an ancient pot.  So, what else would do?  CUP might prefer a piccie that says 'ancient stuff' to someone browsing in a bookshop but they have relaxed that requirement before, so perhaps I have quite a free hand (provided the image can be used without exorbitant fees for rights etc.)

Here's something I like, Thinking Ahead by Yasuo Kuniyoshi.  It at least has something to do with what I've written about:

 
 Failing that, perhaps something very abstract would be best.  Any suggestions?
 

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Strike!

The UCU strike action coughed up an article that made it into Angry People in Local Newspapers. Do click on the link because it takes you to a page where you can view a beautifully edited video that conveys the desolate fury of the strikers. And they are wearing onesies.

UPDATE: to save your clicking-finger, here is the video:

Monday, February 10, 2014

Real fame

My kids were far more impressed to find out I had once supervised yesterday's 'Star in a reasonably priced car'...  (Watch here on YouTube...)

Stig (L) with former Classicist (R)



My amazing media career

I think I was on the wireless yesterday.  (Radio 3, so almost no one will have heard it.)  You can 'catch up' or even 'listen again' here, if you like.  There's also a blog by the person who made the documentary here.


Friday, January 31, 2014

Épicurisme et scepticisme

I haven't seen a copy of this yet but I'm sure it's excellent...  (At least, I remember really enjoying the conference.)



Vient de paraître: Stéphane Marchand-Francesco Verde (éds.), Épicurisme et Scepticisme, Sapienza Università Editrice, Roma 2013, pp. 189, € 17.00

Table des matières

Préface: Pierre-Marie Morel, Emidio Spinelli

Introduction: Stéphane Marchand,  Francesco Verde

PREMIÈRE PARTIE : PROXIMITÉS DU SCEPTICISME ET DE L'ÉPICURISME

Tranquility: Democritus and Pyrrho: Svavar Svavarsson
Chain of Proof in Lucretius, Sextus, and Plato: Rhetorical Tradition and Philosophy: Michael Erler
Scepticisme et thérapeutique : le cas de conscience du dogmatisme épicurien: Julie Giovacchini
Le statut particulier de la philosophie épicurienne dans le néo-pyrrhonisme: Stéphane Marchand

DEUXIÈME PARTIE : ÉPICURISME, CYRÉNAÏSME, SCEPTICISME

Epicureans and Cyrenaics on Pleasure as a Pathos: James Warren
La critique du critère de vérité épicurien chez Sextus Empiricus: un scepticisme sur le monde extérieur ? Diego Machuca

TROISIÈME PARTIE : SEXTUS EMPIRICUS, SOURCE DE L'ÉPICURISME

Epicurean Attitudes toward Geometry: The Sceptical Account: Francesco Verde
Sextus Empiricus et le τέλoς épicurien : le plaisir est-il par nature digne d’être choisi?: Emidio Spinelli

Friday, January 24, 2014

It's lecture/supervision hand-gesture bingo!

See the full set here.

If you can tick off all of them in one hour's lecture or supervision then shout 'Bingo!' and leave the room triumphantly.

Example:


The Dialectic.
‘This is a dialectic and I’m going to explain it.’

Grip imaginary six centimetre object between thumb and forefinger. Rotate wrist ninety degrees, snapping into end position. Smoothly rotate back to start. Repeat up to three times depending on conviction. Use when expressing a shift from one thing to another. Highly infectious.

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Okhlocracy

Now, this looks like it might be fun (tip from Carol, via PAC): Okhlos is a game about an angry mob in ancient Greece. You will have to travel all around Greece and assemble a huge group of angry people, to fight armies, mythological creatures and even gods! Here's a video of the first level. It has some very annoying music.  Find out more here.



And here is one of the bugs the developers have been dealing with: raining Greek philosophers!



Friday, January 17, 2014

Trigger's metaphysics

R.I.P. Roger Lloyd pack.

Here are some wonderful Trigger moments, during which he asserts the continuity thesis of broom-persistence based on a simple empirical method: 'Here's a picture of it.  What more bloody proof do you need?'


Monday, January 13, 2014

CFP: Philosophy of Death

Via Michael Cholbi and the IAPDD:


 We invite all interested scholars to contribute to the program of the inaugural conference of the International Association for the Philosophy of Death of Dying. The conference will be held 20-22 November 2014 on the campus of California State Polytechnic University, Pomona (east of Los Angeles, California).
Abstracts of 500-750 words should address philosophical questions related to death and dying, including but not limited to:

•  the metaphysics of death, including personal identity, criteria for declaring death, etc.
•  the possibility and/or desirability of immortality
•  death as a harm or benefit
•  death and life's meaning
•  reactions to death and dying (e.g., grief, ars moriendi and the 'good death')
•  philosophical implications of death-related technologies (e.g., life extension, cryonics)
•  ethical controversies related to death (suicide, organ donation, etc.)
•  clinical and biomedical issues related to death and dying

KEYNOTE ADDRESSES:

Amy Olberding, University of Oklahoma
John Martin Fischer, University of California- Riverside

Abstracts from scholars outside philosophy are welcome so long as they engage such philosophical issues. Abstracts are welcome from analytic, Continental, and other historical traditions. Abstracts should be submitted to info@philosophyofdeath.org. Deadine for abstract submission: 31 March 2014.

Wednesday, January 08, 2014

Conference: Authors and Authorities in Ancient Philosophy (Cambridge, 15-18 September)

Monday 15–Thursday 18 September 2014

Ancient Greek and Roman philosophy is often characterised in terms of competitive individuals debating orally with one another in public arenas.  But it also developed over its long history a sense in which philosophers might look to an authority and offer to that authority explicit intellectual allegiance.  This is most obvious in the development of the philosophical ‘schools’ with agreed founders and canonical founding texts.  There also developed a tradition of commentary, interpretation, and discussion of texts—composed by ‘authorities’—which often became the focus of disagreement between members of the same school or movement and also useful targets for critics interested in attacking a whole tradition.  Discussing the meaning, force, and even the authorship itself of these texts became a mode of philosophical debate.

This international conference will investigate the twin notions of ‘authorship’ and ‘authority’—the Latin word auctoritas combines these two—in ancient Greek and Roman philosophy.  Topics to be explored include: philosophical allegiance and schism, commentary and quotation, the treatment of anonymous texts or texts of disputed authorship, the collection of authorised corpora of texts and the rejection of spurious or non-canonical works.

The conference also marks the retirement of David Sedley as Laurence Professor of Ancient Philosophy.
ORGANISERS

Dr Jenny Bryan, Department of Greek and Latin, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT ()
Dr Robert Wardy, St Catharine’s College, Cambridge, CB2 1RL ()
Dr James Warren, Corpus Christi College, Cambridge, CB2 1RH ()

The organisers thank the following for their help and financial support: The Faculty of Classics, University of Cambridge; St Catharine's College, Cambridge; University College, London; The British Society for the History of Philosophy; The Mind Association; Cambridge University Press; Oxford University Press.

CONFIRMED SPEAKERS

George Boys-Stones (Durham)
Jenny Bryan (UCL)
David Butterfield (Cambridge)
Nicholas Denyer (Cambridge)
Matt Duncombe (Gröningen)  
Myrto Hatzimichali (Cambridge)
Alex Long (St Andrews) 
A. A. Long (Berkeley)
Roberto Polito
Kelli Rudolph (Kent)
Malcolm Schofield (Cambridge) 
Georgia Tsouni (Bern)
Robert Wardy (Cambridge)
James Warren (Cambridge) 

More details will be posted on the Faculty of Classics website.

Bed and Breakfast accommodation for the nights of 15, 16, and 17 September is available at St Catharine's College. 

Details of costs of accommodation and registration are available here.  You can also use this page to register and pay online.

Rawls and Slote on the pleasures of memory

John Rawls wonders why it is that we might prefer a life in which, given a fixed amount of goods to be distributed over its duration, the goods occur later than a life in which they occur earlier. He wonders whether it has to do with the relatively greater pleasure to be had from increasing expectations.
Other things being equal, we should arrange things at the earlier stages so as to permit a happy life at the later ones. It would seem that for the most part rising expectations are to be preferred. If the value of an activity is assessed relative to its own period, assuming that this is possible, we might try to explain the preference by the relatively greater intensity of the pleasures of anticipation over those of memory. (A Theory of Justice, p. 421). 
Michael Slote (Goods and Virtues, p. 24) mentions Rawls’ suggestion, not to question the relative preference for pleasures of anticipation over those of memory but rather to wonder why Rawls does not think that remembering past goods might at least sometimes be a source of pain instead of pleasure. When we remember a past good, why does Rawls not think we do so with pain? After all, we are ipso facto reminded that the pleasure is past and gone.  This would be another reason why it is better for pleasures to be in the future rather than the past.

Well, it depends I suppose, particularly on the context in which one is doing the remembering and the kind of good that is being remembered. (Aristotle is quite sensible about this kind of thing. I’ve spent quite a lot of time thinking about his and the Epicureans’ differing approaches to the pleasures and pains of remembering and anticipating pleasures and pains. I think Aristotle is right to say that we can sometimes remember with pleasure even a past pain.) And Slote’s point might have a mirror image in anticipations too. Similarly, I suppose, when we anticipate a pleasure, might we not feel pain at the thought that the pleasure being anticipated is just not yet here? I think some young children anticipating a birthday or Christmas might find the thought of the pleasures to come not itself pleasant but perhaps rather painful. Looking forward to Christmas just reminds you that it’s not Christmas yet.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Sneaky peak

I've still not yet set eyes on a physical copy of the Routledge Companion to Ancient Philosophy, edited by Frisbee Sheffield and me.

But if you go to the Routledge site you can get a peak of the contents.  They will even let you browse the first thirty pages which includes such thrills as the list of abbreviations and my very brief introduction.  You can also try out the 'widget' below.